Ok, this is my first time editing in a Wikia so I might do it wrong and in that case I apologize. But in my current playthrough with the latest patch on current post date giving the offering to Finn I have Cole, Sera and Varric. I get no approval from Cole and only a "slightly approves" from Sera. Varric stays as stated on the page with a "slightly approves". Guessing its a game update so I'm changing the approval parts to reflect my experience removing Cole approval and reducing Sera from Approves to Slightly approves.
Also in further experimentation Cassandra gives no Approval to neither Finn nor the Huntsman and in testing both scenarios with both party members only Sera, Varric and Vivienne offers any approval at all. Therefore I am changing this page to reflect this experience.
- I'd have to double check but looks sound to me.