Yes. But you insisted that he present the gift to you first, before the feast. This way, you can decide whether to relay it to the Divine.
Success: -4 Twilight (and the Divine stays for the rest of the feast)
Let him present his gift. This is unlikely to go well. It'll be an evening to remember, but you'll be lucky if the Divine doesn't set her Templars on you.
Result: The Divine is outraged at the gift and leaves in disgust. Serault's Shame is not lifted and the game ends immediately. You lose.