Bhelen

Even if you think having a caste system and isoating from the outside world is good all of harrowmonts endings are bad for orzammar

Is this even a question? Yeah sure Bhelen is a murderous prick (what King isn't though?) but he's the clear choice for a better political leader. He actually at least tries to get rid of the worse elements of Dwarven society. The only time you shouldn't put him on the throne is if you're the Dwarf Noble Warden because you obviously can't trust him...I know it actually works out well but lorewise it's stupid.

Bhelen is a murderous bastard, but in most ways he's a more effective leader than Harrowmont. This is the point and power of the Dwarven questline; there are good and bad to both choices.

Noob= Harrowmont because he's a good guy!

Pro Gamer= Bhelen because it's 100% the right choice duh.

^ Well, neither way affects your gameplay in any way, so it's less noob vs oldtimer than an RP issue.

Honestly since I very seldom play dwarves (where you have some prior knowledge and understanding of the issues), I figure they have no business expecting me to pick a king for them and if they don't like the choice they should have done it themselves. ;)

^^What Asheluned said. There are RP reasons to pick either one. Being a Noob or "Pro Gamer" (What does this mean, really? Certainly not literally a pro gamer - no e-sports involve Origins) has nothing to do with it.