Talk:Pick

Playing on the PC (Ultimate Edition, fully patched up) I got the following results: Along with the sword you get 100 XP in any case; Alistair objects only if you kill Pick (-3).
 * Wardens failing the persuasion check can brow-beat Pick into giving up the sword, and they can also kill him afterwards
 * Wardens who succeed at the persuasion check can only continue with more persuasion, and they leave Pick as pleased as Punch (until his master catches up with him, presumably)

Afterwards you can find Pick on one of the platforms overlooking the valley, if he is still alive; he appears dejected but if you talk to him you'll find that he was just pensive. KnightOwl42 (talk) 13:15, January 19, 2014 (UTC)